Back to blog

Why does AI grading still leave teachers buried in disputes?

Thắng Đoàn
Thắng Đoàn

You want to hand grading to AI and get your evenings back. But when 73.5 percent of surveyed teachers reject essay grading outright, the problem is clearly not typing speed. It is trust.

Teachers do not trust the output

The Korea Times reports a survey of 2,427 middle and high school teachers in South Korea, where 73.5 percent opposed adding written-response and essay questions to the CSAT. Their stated reasons clustered around grading disputes, complaint handling, consistency, and workload. Teachers also questioned whether AI grading could reliably assess subject-specific answers. The problem is not writing the feedback. It is defending every score afterward.

  • Survey allowed up to two reasons each: disputes and consistency dominated
  • Only a small minority supported the change outright

Speed comes from review, not autonomy

The Irish Times describes Diotima, an Irish AI platform that drafts student-specific feedback from an institution's own curriculum and learning outcomes. Humans stay in the loop: trainers and teachers review the AI drafts before students see them. The same pattern appears in the UAE, where Gulf News reports Alef Education's AI Auto Grading tool supports routine assessment tasks rather than replacing the teacher. In both cases the tool drafts, the teacher approves. That is how quality survives.

  • Diotima gives formative feedback while students are still working
  • Alef Education frames its tool as support, not replacement

The time saved is real but partial

Per TES, an Education Endowment Foundation trial found primary teachers using Oak National Academy's AI assistant Aila reduced their planning time. Yet views on the tool's longer-term effectiveness were mixed, and newer teachers used it more than experienced colleagues. AI assistance reliably trims routine work. It does not yet convince experienced professionals that the output matches their judgment.

  • Newer teachers adopted the tool more readily than veterans
  • Effectiveness beyond the short term remained contested

What this does not solve

None of these tools resolves the accountability question. When a parent challenges a grade, someone must explain and defend the decision, and that someone is still the teacher. Diotima's own design assumes human review of every AI draft, which means the review workload never disappears. High-stakes, subjective assessment stays risky even with AI drafting.

Which of your grading tasks are routine enough to hand to an AI drafter today?
If a parent challenged an AI-assisted grade tomorrow, who defends it and how?

List your five most repetitive assessment tasks and mark which ones a human must still sign off.

Sources

The Korea Times

The Irish Times

Gulf News

TES

Share:

Recommended for you

Enjoyed this article?

Subscribe for new articles. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

By subscribing you agree to receive the newsletter. No spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime.