Back to blog

Why do schools buy AI tools nobody uses?

Thắng Đoàn
Thắng Đoàn

Your district signed an AI contract, and teachers quietly skipped it. Enthusiasm is high, yet usage of dedicated institutional tools is near zero.

Everyone uses AI, but not your AI tool

Per EdTech Magazine, about 9 in 10 students, educators and education leaders say they have already used AI for school. Yet Instructure's EdTech Top 40, covering nearly 19.5 million U.S. higher education users, found no dedicated AI tool ranks among the Top 100. People use general AI, not the tools institutions buy.

The claims outran the evidence

EdSurge reports that EdReports released a brief on verifying the efficacy of digital instructional tools, because vendors are adding AI features and often claiming they are educationally effective. The discussion raises hard questions for district leaders weighing an edtech purchase. Some tools let teachers review content first; others put content in front of students in real time. Those are different risk profiles, often sold the same way.

  • Ask vendors for efficacy evidence before renewal, not after.
  • Check whether teachers can review AI output before students see it.

The stack already has a shape

Per Instructure, content, collaboration and video tools account for more than half of the Top 40, and formal AI integration remains limited. The environment is built around content, connection and institutional infrastructure. Dedicated AI tools sit outside that stack, so they sit unused.

What this does not solve

Willingness is not the problem. EdTech Magazine reports that students and educators want to use AI but are asking for more support to do so. Even tools inside the existing stack fail without training and teacher involvement. Vivek Varshney of SpeEdLabs argues hybrid models must balance technology with teacher-led instruction. No procurement decision fixes that on its own.

Which of your current edtech licenses have usage data you have never checked?
If teachers cannot review AI output before students see it, should that tool be in classrooms at all?

Pull last term's usage logs for your three newest AI licenses and compare them against your existing LMS tools.

Sources

Instructure EdTech Top 40 for Higher Education

EdSurge: Can Schools Trust AI Features in Edtech Products?

SiliconIndia: How EdTech-School Partnerships Are Redefining Digital Learning

EdTech Magazine: Microsoft Report on Higher Education AI Adoption

Share:

Recommended for you

Enjoyed this article?

Subscribe for new articles. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

By subscribing you agree to receive the newsletter. No spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime.