Back to blog

Should patients see what the AI heard in their visit?

Thắng Đoàn
Thắng Đoàn

You assumed the recording of your visit was your record. A Washington state court just said no, and that gap widens as AI moves from note-taking into decision support.

The ruling: AI audio is not your record

In one of the first rulings on AI in medicine, a Washington state court denied a patient access to the ambient AI recording of her telehealth visit. Clinical Advisor reports the court classified the recordings as internal administrative tools, similar to traditional dictation or handwritten notes, exempting them from patient disclosure requests under a Washington state Act. The clinic's system, per Clinical Advisor, processes the clinician-patient conversation into a draft note that the clinician reviews and edits before it enters the chart. Only the edited note is the record. The raw conversation is not.

AI is moving from scribe to advisor

The legal gap widens because vendors are not standing still. Newsweek reports Suki and Wolters Kluwer launched Ask, a clinical decision support tool combining UpToDate medical reference with patient-specific context from Suki's ambient platform, inside the Suki for Clinicians app. Per Oracle's announcement, its Clinical AI Agent now gives nurses voice-driven chart navigation and AI-generated acute nursing summaries inside the EHR. The same class of systems that record visits increasingly shapes what clinicians see and decide.

Why an edited note is not an auditable record

Clinical Advisor notes the clinician can review and edit the AI output before it becomes the final chart note. That means the patient sees a curated artifact, not what the system actually captured or generated. If an AI summary omits or distorts what was said, this ruling gives patients no right to request the underlying recording to check it. The result is asymmetric transparency: the vendor sees everything, the patient sees an edited note.

What this does not solve

The ruling settles one state law question, not the policy one. Per Clinical Advisor, it treats AI recordings as administrative tools under one Washington state Act. It does not say recordings should be hidden, and it offers no guidance on decision support tools like Suki's Ask, which never produce audio at all. Vendors' efficiency claims, such as Oracle's promise of near real-time documentation, say nothing about patient access rights.

If a patient disputed your AI-generated visit note today, could your organization produce the underlying recording?
Where do you draw the line between scribe output patients might check and decision support they never see?

Ask your EHR or scribe vendor one question: who owns the raw audio, and can a patient request it?

Sources

Clinical Advisor: Court rules patients cannot access ambient AI recordings

Newsweek: Suki, UpToDate bring AI clinical decision support into workflows

PR Newswire: Oracle Health Clinical AI Agent for nurses

Share:

Recommended for you

Enjoyed this article?

Subscribe for new articles. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

By subscribing you agree to receive the newsletter. No spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime.